claude-opus-5-5
Cherry tree from seed to bloom — critic loop, third version
A benchmark run on an experimental variant of the skills, not on released plugin code: Plugin 0.7.0 plus unreleased skill and agent changes from commit 738aeb4: A draft with no BLOCKING finding shipped as it was; a fix round was kept only if one critic call, shown the old and new versions blind, chose the new one; a fix touching more than a quarter of a layer counted as a redraw and was restored; objects that grow on screen were drawn at three or four hand-made sizes. Each step ran in its own fresh omp session (claude-opus-5-5, thinking high), launched through Herdr one after another, with the tree-growth step text sent verbatim after the `/skill:studio ` command prefix; the operator created the document and loaded PICO-8 before step 1 and handed step 2 a copy of the saved step-1 file. omp's built-in advisor was on, as in the earlier omp runs. No image model, no reference, no messages beyond the step text. Blind: the best of three tree runs.
- Author
- Nik Fedorov @fedorovvvv
- Date
- Plugin
- v0.7.0
- Harness
- omp
- Model
- claude-opus-5-5 ran every step
- Reference
- none — drawn from the prompt alone
- Tags
- nature animation growth benchmark 64x64 pico-8 experiment
The prompts, verbatim
Step 1:The tree
The document is already open: 64×64 pixels, RGB, with the PICO-8 palette loaded (16 colours). Use only those 16 colours — do not add, widen or replace the palette. This brief is complete: do not ask me to confirm it. Decide anything it leaves open yourself and list those decisions in your final report. Coordinates below are 0-based pixels, x to the right, y down. Draw ONE frame: a cherry tree in full bloom standing on a strip of ground. A later step will animate this tree growing from a seed, so build it as a clear structure — trunk, a few main branches, blossom masses — rather than texture noise. Composition - Transparent sky. Front view, the tree centred. - Ground strip across the full width, y 56–63: a grass edge on y 56–57 (#008751 with #00e436 tufts), soil below it (#5f574f with #000000 shading and a few #ab5236 pebbles). - Trunk rising from the ground with its base centred on x 30–33, slightly flared roots visible where it meets the grass. The trunk is 4 px wide at the base, tapers upward, and curves gently in an S. - Around y=36 the trunk splits into exactly 3 main branches (left, centre, right), each splitting again at least once. Branches thin to 1 px at the tips. - The canopy spans roughly x 8–56 and y 6–38: three or four rounded blossom masses with gaps between them where branches show through. Colours (PICO-8 hex values) - Bark: #ab5236 lit side, #7e2553 shadow side, #000000 for the deepest crevices. - Blossoms: #ff77a8 base, #ffccaa and #fff1e8 highlights, #7e2553 shadow. A few green leaves (#00e436, #008751) peek out between the blossoms. Style - Light from the upper left: lit sides of the trunk and the blossom masses on the left and top, shadow on the right and underneath. - Blossoms are drawn as clusters of 2–5 px clumps with a clear light and shadow side, not single-pixel noise. No stray pixels, no anti-aliasing against transparency. Layers, exactly these names, bottom to top: `ground`, `trunk` (trunk, roots and every branch), `canopy` (blossoms and leaves). No other layers. Before you finish: look at the result, run validate, and fix what it reports. In your final report, describe the branch structure (where each main branch splits) and any decision you made that the brief did not specify.
Step 2:The growth
The open document holds a blossoming cherry tree on a strip of ground (canvas 64×64, PICO-8 palette, layers `ground`, `trunk`, `canopy`). Keep the palette — use only its 16 colours. This brief is complete: do not ask me to confirm it. Decide anything it leaves open yourself and list those decisions in your final report. Coordinates are 0-based pixels, x to the right, y down. Animate this tree growing from a seed into exactly the tree in the document. 18 to 24 frames in total, one tag named `grow` covering every frame, direction forward. The final frame IS the existing tree, pixel for pixel, on `ground`, `trunk` and `canopy`. Keep the current art as the last frame and build every earlier stage backwards from it: each earlier frame is a smaller version of the same structure, so every branch grows along the path its final branch takes. Stages, in this order 1. Seed, 2 frames: no tree. A 2×2 seed lies half-buried in the soil directly under the trunk's final base. 2. Sprout, 2–3 frames: the soil cracks open around the seed, a few dirt crumbs pop up, then a thin green stem rises with two round seed leaves unfolding. 3. Sapling, 3–4 frames: the stem turns to bark colour from the bottom up and grows taller, the first side branches appear, a few small green leaves. 4. Young tree, 4–5 frames: the trunk thickens from 1 px to its final width from the bottom up, the 3 main branches extend along their final paths and split, and green leaf clusters swell into the shapes of the final blossom masses. 5. Budding, 2–3 frames: the green masses reach their final outlines and pink buds dot them. 6. Bloom, 3–4 frames: the buds burst open cluster by cluster, spreading from the branch tips inward, until the canopy matches the final tree. A few loose petals drift down and to the right across these frames. Rules - The `ground` layer is identical on every frame. Soil cracks, crumbs and falling petals go on a new layer named `fx`, which is empty on the final frame. - Growth is continuous: the trunk and branches never shrink, never jump to a new position and never change path between frames. The trunk base stays on x 30–33 throughout. - The pace eases: very little changes per frame at the start, the biggest change per frame comes in the middle (a growth spurt), and the last frames settle in small steps. - Timing (milliseconds per frame): the seed frames at least 400 each, the growth frames 80–150, and the final frame at least 1500 so the finished tree holds before the loop restarts. Before you finish: check the whole cycle as a filmstrip, check at least one young-tree frame with onion skin against its neighbours, compare the final frame against the tree you started from, and run validate. Fix what it reports. In your final report, give the frame plan: frame number, stage and duration for every frame.
Benchmark results
13 of 13 criteria passed.
- Passed:
validate passes with no unaddressed errors (warnings may stand if the report names and justifies them).
· Step 1,
tree-validatevalidate passes: score 95, 0 errors, one outline warning on trunk (70% #ab5236, 46 edge px) which the agent called a false positive for an unoutlined two-tone trunk.
- Passed:
Every colour is on the PICO-8 palette and the palette still has exactly the 16 PICO-8 entries (validate check palette, palette op="get").
· Step 1,
tree-palettepalette op get returns exactly the 16 PICO-8 entries.
- Passed:
The preview reads at a glance as a cherry tree in bloom — trunk, branches showing through gaps, and pink blossom masses are each distinguishable without the ascii grid.
· Step 1,
tree-readTrunk, forked branches and three pink masses read at a glance in the 4× export.
- Passed:
The brief is followed: layers exactly ground/trunk/canopy (sprite_info), ground on y 56–63 with grass on top, trunk base on x 30–33 and 4 px wide, exactly 3 main branches splitting around y=36, canopy inside roughly x 8–56 and y 6–38 as 3–4 masses with gaps.
· Step 1,
tree-specLayers ground/trunk/canopy; ground y56–63; trunk 4 px wide at y47–54 on x29–32/30–33 with flared roots; three branches fork at y≈35 and each twigs again; canopy x7–57, y7–37 as three separate masses with gaps.
- Passed:
Light reads from the upper left on the trunk and on every blossom mass, and the blossoms are clumps with a light and shadow side rather than single-pixel noise (validate strays clean, look op="ascii").
· Step 1,
tree-shadingLight from the upper left: cream on top left of each mass, #7e2553 shadow to the right and underneath; masses are clumps, though the cream fills much of each mass and is a bit busy.
- Passed:
The sprite has 18–24 frames and tag op="list" shows a forward tag named `grow` covering all of them.
· Step 2,
grow-tagged20 frames; tag grow 1–20, direction forward.
- Passed:
The final frame matches the step-1 tree pixel for pixel — an image diff of its PNG export against the step-1 export shows no changed pixel — and `fx` is empty on that frame.
· Step 2,
grow-finalFrame 20 composite and ground, trunk and canopy cels are pixel-identical to step1.aseprite (0 differing pixels); fx empty on frame 20.
- Passed:
The filmstrip shows all six stages in order — seed, sprout with two seed leaves, sapling, thickening young tree, green masses with buds, bloom spreading from the tips.
· Step 2,
grow-stagesFilmstrip: seed, cracking soil with crumbs, sprout with seed leaves, bark sapling with side branches and small leaves, thickening young tree, green masses with buds, bloom from the tips with petals.
- Passed:
look op="diff" with layer="trunk" between consecutive growth frames shows only additions and re-shading along the existing structure — no branch shrinks, jumps or changes path, and onion skin on a young-tree frame shows its branches lying on the paths of the final ones.
· Step 2,
grow-continuousTrunk layer loses 0 pixels between consecutive frames and no trunk pixel on any frame lies outside the final trunk's pixels.
- Passed:
The ground layer never changes (look op="diff" with layer="ground" reports nothing changed between any two frames) and the trunk base stays on x 30–33 on every frame.
· Step 2,
grow-groundGround cel identical on all 20 frames; trunk base on x31 then x30–33, widening to x28–35 only as the roots flare.
- Passed:
look op="diff" percentChanged between consecutive frames is small at the start, largest in the middle and small again at the end — the growth visibly spurts and settles.
· Step 2,
grow-easingComposite change 0.0–0.7% for frames 2–8, peak 6.6% at frame 12, then 1.5–4.1% over the bloom, 0.7% on the last step.
- Passed:
frame op="list" durations match the brief — seed frames ≥400, growth frames 80–150, final frame ≥1500 ms.
· Step 2,
grow-timingSeed frames 600/450 ms, growth frames 80–150 ms, final frame 1800 ms.
- Passed:
validate passes with no unaddressed errors and the palette is still the 16 PICO-8 entries.
· Step 2,
grow-validatevalidate passes, 0 errors, 18 outline warnings on partial-growth frames, expected for unoutlined intermediate stages; palette is the 16 PICO-8 entries.
Validate reports
What the plugin's own lint said at the end of each step.
- Step 1 Passed Score 95 0 errors, 1 warning
- Step 2 Passed Score 10 0 errors, 18 warnings
Craft
50% from 1 judge, each axis scored 0–4 against the rubric.
| Judge | Read | Form | Motion | Cohesion | Appeal | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| fedorovvvv human | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | Overall 5/10, given as one number on the rating page of 2026-10-07; each axis set to round(5/10 × 4) = 2. |
| Mean | 2.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 | 50% |
Run metrics
What each step cost, as the harness reported it.
| Step | Minutes | Tool calls | Output tokens | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 15.6 | 88 | 88,366 | $5.76 |
| 2 | 25 | 149 | 139,366 | $8.82 |
| Total | 40.6 | 237 | 227,732 | $14.58 |
More views
Step 1, 4× , step 1

Every frame, 2× , step 2
Files
| File | Role | Step | Size | Download |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| anim.gif The animation, 4× | Cover | 2 | 26.8 KB | Downloadanim.gif |
| step1.aseprite Step 1 | Aseprite source | 1 | 1.3 KB | Downloadstep1.aseprite |
| step1.png Step 1, 4× | Frame | 1 | 2.4 KB | Downloadstep1.png |
| step2.aseprite Step 2 | Aseprite source | 2 | 11.2 KB | Downloadstep2.aseprite |
| filmstrip.png Every frame, 2× | Filmstrip | 2 | 10.1 KB | Downloadfilmstrip.png |